11 Holiday Pies Like Grandma Used To Make + 2 Pie Crust Recipes That Would Make Grandma Proud
This post may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through links on this site, I may earn a commission.
Read my Privacy Policy.
Pies and holidays go together no matter what time of year it is. But during the winter holidays, they tend to take on a bit more meaning and nostalgia. If holiday pies make you think of the holidays at grandma’s house, you won’t want to miss this collection of eleven holiday pie recipes. They are made from scratch but still simple to make with easy-to-find ingredients. Keep your holiday traditions alive this year with the perfect pie.
1. Pumpkin Pie From Scratch
Your holiday meal won’t be complete without a pumpkin pie. This homemade pie is healthier than the store-bought versions and even more delicious. Be prepared to hand out copies of the recipe because everyone will be asking you for it.
2. Fresh Cranberry Pie
Fresh cranberries aren’t just for cranberry sauce, you can use them to make this fresh cranberry pie too. This delicious pie with a healthy homemade crust is sure to be a hit around the dinner table, and there is no refined sugar included. Grandma would be proud of this delicious pie.
3. Naturally Sweetened Pecan Pie
This naturally sweetened pecan pie is so much better for you than the versions with corn syrup, and it’s still sweet and delicious. Instead of corn syrup, the sweetness comes from honey for a depth of flavor you will adore. This healthy pie recipe is the recipe you need for all of your holiday gatherings this year.
4. From Scratch Apple Pie
From-scratch apple pie is delicious and it’s so much easier to make than you might think. Apple pie is an American staple and there is always room for one at the table. Make grandma proud this year by serving a delicious and healthy homemade apple pie.
5. Easy Peanut Butter Pie
If you are looking for a creamy and delicious dessert, you need to make this easy peanut butter pie. It’s decadent, rich, and much healthier than store-bought thanks to its all-natural ingredients. Everyone will love this decadent holiday dessert.
6. Banana Cream Pie
Banana cream pie is the perfect creamy dessert no matter what season it is. This pie doesn’t have to be made all at once, so if you are feeling overwhelmed with the holidays you can make it in steps. If you do make the whole pie at once, you can store it in the fridge for 3-4 days and it will still be amazing.
7. Easy Chocolate Pie
Easy chocolate pie is rich, smooth, and decadent. It’s basically rich chocolate pudding in a delicious pie crust. This holiday pie will rival Grandma’s and will be requested every year. Just make sure to add some homemade whipped cream for the ultimate topping.
8. Lemon Cream Pie
Lemon cream pie is the perfect sweet and tart dessert to complete a savory holiday meal. It has a nice strong lemon flavor and it’s very refreshing after a heavy meal. This simple and delicious pie is sure to be a holiday hit.
9. Coconut Meringue Pie
Coconut meringue pie is the perfect holiday dessert. A delicious, flaky crust, filled with a rich creamy custard and topped with a delicious meringue. If meringue is not your thing you can easily swap it for whipped cream and turn this into a coconut cream pie.
10. Kabocha Pie
Kabocha pie is every bit as delicious, if not better than, pumpkin pie. Kabocha, or Japanese pumpkin, tastes like a combination of butternut squash and a pumpkin and it makes a very tasty pie. Top it with fresh whipped cream and enjoy.
11. Sweet Potato Pie
Sweet potato pie is an American holiday staple and you are going to love this delicious and healthier version. Sweet potato pie is easy to make and it’s just as good sweetened with maple syrup or honey. You will love the delicious homemade pie crust too.
12. Whole Wheat Pie Crust
This whole wheat pie crust recipe is a great kitchen staple. You can use it for so many different recipes from pies to quiches. This crust works for sweet and savory recipes and it’s really easy to make.
13. Oat Flour Pie Crust
This oat flour pie crust is gluten-free and flaky, and you can freeze it baked or unbaked to use for later. It’s so easy to make, that you’ll never need to buy a store-bought pie crust again. Use this crust for sweet, and savory recipes that everyone will love.
More From The Gracious Pantry
If you love baking cookies for the holidays, try this collection of delicious treats that are sure to inspire the holiday spirit in you. Decorate to your heart’s content, and don’t forget to share a few this season.
