Homemade Uncrustables Recipe

These homemade uncrustables are a far healthier option than the ones you buy at the store and the filling options are endless!

I have to be honest, the whole idea of an Uncrustable really puts me off. I know they are popular, but I never even knew they existed until recently. And when I found out what they were, well… I just didn’t get it.

Maybe it’s my old fashion upbringing, but the idea of eating bread without crust is crazy to me. I know there are kids with sensory issues and what not, but for an average kid… I just don’t get it. The crust is part of the bread! I know if I had asked my grandmother to cut the crusts off my bread when I was little, I would have gotten a good long lecture about how my family went without food in the war. And then I would have eaten the crusts. But I suppose things have changed with time.

Clean Eating Uncrustables Recipe

Please note that the word, “Uncrustables” is the registered trademark of Smuckers. The Gracious Pantry does not lay claim to this trademark in any way. It is used here for reference only.

Another thing I just don’t get is, it’s a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. It takes more time and work to go to the store, park, buy a box of these chemical-filled contraptions and drive home again. then it does to just make a simple PB&J at home. Homemade is cheaper too!! I guess I just don’t see the convenience in them. If I fed these to Mini Chef, he would never be able to sit still in class and he certainly wouldn’t feel full or satisfied after eating. There is almost no nutritional value to help fill him up! He’d be in trouble all the time thanks to his sugar high, never mind the anti-peanut policy at his school.

Nope, I just don’t get it. But for those folks who do purchase them, I thought I’d try my hand at a few different variations of this “sandwich” just to show you that they can be made much healthier while still being tasty.

Clean Eating Uncrustables Recipe

I did a peanut butter and jelly version just to get my feet wet. They turned out pretty good. I found out the trick is to make sure you put peanut butter on both sides of the bread so that the jelly doesn’t soak through the bread. You also can’t overfill these or the edges won’t seal shut. But beyond that, it was really just a PB&J guys. It took more work to make them this way, but if you must have them, at least you have a healthier option. If your kids just won’t eat the crust, these are nice to make at home. And yes, you can freeze them. Just package them up separately and then freeze. You can store them together once frozen, although I do recommend putting a piece of parchment between them if they are all in the same container.


Clean Eating Uncrustables Recipe
Honey and Banana with Cinnamon.
Clean Eating Uncrustables Recipe
Avocado, hummus and tomato. – Do not freeze.


  • Tuna fish – Do not freeze.
  • Hummus & carrots, cucumbers – Do not freeze.
  • Cheese & tomato uncrustableS – Do not freeze.
  • Avocado, tomato & cheese – Do not freeze.

I will say that the one benefit I found with these types of sandwiches is that there is far less mess. Because they are sealed around the edges, food doesn’t fall out at the bottom while your child is eating. So if your kid really must have these types of sandwiches, you now have a way to give it to them without worrying about sugar overload at lunch time, or jelly stains on their shirt or pants!


You will need this tool to make these types of sandwiches. It simultaneously cuts off the crust and seals the sandwich shut around the edges. However, if you do not want to purchase one of these, you can also cut the crust off yourself with a knife and then use a fork to crimp the edges shut.

Get the one I used on amazon here: Affordable Sandwich Sealer n Decruster (color May Vary)

Get round decruster instead on amazon here: The Pampered Chef Cut N Seal, Medium, 3-1/2-Inch 1195
Clean Eating Uncrustables Recipe

Copyright Information For The Gracious Pantry


Clean Eating Uncrustables Recipe

Clean Eating Uncrustables

A healthier way to give your kids the lunch they want.
5 from 2 votes
Print Pin Rate Add to Collection
Course: Sandwiches
Cuisine: American
Prep Time: 5 minutes
Total Time: 5 minutes
Servings: 1 uncrustable
Calories: 353kcal
Author: Tiffany McCauley


  • 2 slices whole grain bread (no sugar added)
  • 2 tbsp. natural peanut butter (no sugar added)
  • 1 tbsp. 100% fruit spread


  • Lay the bread down on a flat work surface.
  • Spread the peanut butter on first, 1 tbsp. on each slice. Spread the peanut butter in a circle in the center of the bread so as not to have it cut away when the crust is removed.
  • Add the fruit spread to the center of one slice, then close the sandwich.
  • Use the cutter to remove the crust and seal the sandwich closed.
  • You can freeze these for up to 2 months.


Please note that the nutrition data below is a ballpark figure. Exact data is not possible.


Serving: 1entire recipe | Calories: 353kcal | Carbohydrates: 39g | Protein: 14g | Fat: 16g | Saturated Fat: 3g | Sodium: 364mg | Potassium: 330mg | Fiber: 5g | Sugar: 13g | Vitamin C: 1.3mg | Calcium: 73mg | Iron: 1.9mg

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


  1. This looks intriguing!

    Do you take the ‘uncrustables’ out of the freezer the night before or that morning?

    And have your tried using deli meats? Do they freeze?

    1. The Gracious Pantry says:

      Debra – Yes, I would take them out the night before and then pack them really well with ice packs to keep them cold. I don’t eat deli meats, but I have frozen them in the past. Things like sliced turkey get a tiny bit grainy after freezing, but not bad enough to notice in a sandwich. Many deli meats do just fine if they aren’t in the freezer for too long. I wouldn’t go over a month.

  2. Hi Tiffany, this is a cool idea for kids and seniors alike, in some cases. While I LOVE the heel on fresh bread, I have to say that store-bought bread definitely lacks in crust quality. One thing I don’t see is this said tool. What does it look like, how does it work, and where can we get it? Thank you.

    1. The Gracious Pantry says:

      Jody – It’s linked right above the recipe and copyright button. I’ll make the image bigger so it’s not so easy to miss. ๐Ÿ™‚

  3. Diana Didi Martin says:

    5 stars
    I never thought of using these for tuna!! I love tuna sandwiches, but hate taking them to work because of the (bit smelly) mess they make on my hands. New lunch idea. Thanks! <3

    1. The Gracious Pantry says:

      Diana – My pleasure! It’s definitely a more neat and tidy approach to a tuna fish sandwich. ๐Ÿ™‚

  4. Ah there it is. Thanks. : )

    1. The Gracious Pantry says:

      Jody – Sure! ๐Ÿ™‚